Coalition formed against sanit garage

The Brookdale site as seen from Waterside (Photo by Maria Rocha-Buschel)

The Brookdale site as seen from Waterside (Photo by Maria Rocha-Buschel)

By Maria Rocha-Buschel

Tenant groups against the proposed sanitation garage at the Brookdale campus organized themselves just in time for another public scoping hearing that took place at the site of proposed facility on Wednesday.

 The Brookdale Neighborhood Coalition announced their formation on Tuesday in the form of a press release. The individual tenant organizations have been fighting the construction of the garage since it was announced almost three years ago but this is the first time that the groups have officially come together to oppose the plan. The coalition consists of the tenant associations at Waterside Plaza, Stuyvesant Town-Peter Cooper Village, East Midtown Plaza and the Kips Bay Neighborhood Association.

The Economic Development Corporation had invited community members to provide their input on the project through a working group, but this venture was designed to discuss plans for the bookend sites, not the garage itself.

Janet Handal, president of the Waterside Tenants Association, said that many members of the community were hopeful and then quickly discouraged by the purpose of the working group because most people primarily wanted to discuss how to prevent the garage and talking about the outer parcels was less of a priority.

“(DSNY) said the time to talk about the garage would be at public meetings so we organized after last public meeting and decided we would be more effective as one voice,” Handal said.

The coalition aims to keep higher standards for the DSNY in terms of its requirements for the projected studies that the department will be conducting and a formal response will be released on July 22. At that time, the coalition will outline its concerns on pedestrian safety, traffic, air quality and other issues.

Tenants are concerned about the fact that DSNY says a public health analysis of the project is not warranted.

“When you start looking at the data, Gramercy has the worst health

quality and that’s from the mayor’s own portal,” Handal said. “DSNY says, ‘well, we use ultra clean diesel,’ but that does not do anything with the fine particulate matter. The filters on the trucks reduce that pollution by 90 percent, which is good, but that’s not all of it so you have a net increase of pollution. The devil is in the details, as they say.”

Other issues that the coalition is worried about involve pedestrian safety, especially because of the area’s proximity to a number of schools, in addition to the multiple residential housing complexes. Traffic is another concern: according to data from the city website for Vision Zero, there is a high density of traffic-related incidents in the area and there was a 30 percent increase in collisions from 2009 to 2014.

“When you go back and think about what Mayor de Blasio’s goals were with Vision Zero, the first responsibility of government is to protect its citizens,” Handal said. “How is that happening here?”

The group is also hoping to highlight some points that they feel the draft EIS has missed in terms of comprehensive analysis of the garage’s impact, including the identification of alternative locations and not adequately studying the health hazards.

The last public scoping hearing, which was scheduled for July 15 (after T&V’s press time), was meant to gather comments that will be incorporated into the Draft Environmental Impact Statement. Residents will get a 30-day period in which to respond and then the final Environmental Impact Statement will be released. Handal said that she’s not optimistic that DSNY is open to a discussion addressing all of the community’s concerns, but she has been motivated by her investigation into the hazards to keep trying anyway.

“I sometimes get lulled into the notion of a kinder, gentler garage,” she admitted, “but when I do the research it’s so upsetting because we’re right next door.”

A spokesperson from the DSNY was not immediately available for comment on the coalition.

5 thoughts on “Coalition formed against sanit garage

  1. If you live near 14th Street and think this doesn’t affect you, wait until the traffic is backed up even more as 180 sanitation vehicles take to our already gridlocked streets.

  2. This will really enhance this neighborhood. It will blend nicely with the noise pollution from the pile drivers that start at 7 am on the construction site at Ave A and 14th. Just can’t wait till they start the demolition and construction on the rest of the south side of 14th from First Avenue eastward. The construction will result in thousands more residents in the neighborhood to use Sty Town to walk and toilet their dogs, jostle for space on the sidewalks and I guess there will be a lottery system for who can get onto the L train. So I think the noise and stench pollution from the proposed sanitation garage will just add to the general charm and ambience of living here. Whoop-de-doo! Aren’t we lucky! Ya just gotta hand it to those Town Planners!

  3. The Brookdale Coalition has brought to light some very disconcerting information about this neighborhood, especially the studies about the traffic accidents and poor air quality in Gramercy Park. Equally disconcerting is their use of scare tactics and hyperbole to make their case against the Sanitation garage.

    For example, this new group was apparently behind a recently published half-page ad in Town & Village that incorrectly announced in a big headline that the Brookdale meeting on July 15th was “Final Public Meeting.” It turns out that is not true, and was apparently just a scare tactic to get more people to attend the meeeting. As Dan Garodnick and others at the meeting pointed out, there will be many more meetings on this important issue. Why any group would be allowed to publish an ad with a false claim in T&V anonymously is another question. I would recommend T&V publish the names of this group and any future group that buys advertising so that they an be held accountable for theiir claims.

    Another scare tactic is right on The Brookdale Coalition’s new Facebook page. They claim that Gramercy Park has the “worst” are quality in Manhattan, a claim that for anyone who has been in Midtown at rush hour is had to believe. But according to the City’s air quality report, while Gramercy’s air quality is “worse” than the overall city average (as is most of Manhattan), it is certainly not the “worst” in the city; that honor belongs to the South Bronx and Upper Manhattan. While air quality in the area is below average, it has been steadily improving over the past several years. Once this battle is over, perhaps these community leaders can turn their attention to improving the air quality in the area, and not just use it as a scare tactic or a bargaining chip when it suits them.

    Using scare tactics and making false claims that can be easily debunked by the public and by the Department of Sanitation does not help them make their case, it just makes this look like a desperate last ditch attempt to derail a project that by all appearances now is well on its way to getting the approvals needed to begin construction. The planning for this garage has been underway for several years,and it appears The Brookdale Coalition is a bit late to the game. If they are going to stop or alter the Brookdale plan then they need to stick to the facts and come up with some real alternatives, which so far they have failed to do.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.