Mariella Pizza closes doors after 37 years

Mariella Pizza closed due to a gas issue in January, then never reopened. (Photo by Sabina Mollot)

Mariella Pizza closed due to a gas issue in January, then never reopened. (Photo by Sabina Mollot)

By Sabina Mollot

Mariella Pizza, which had slung slices for 37 years on Third Avenue before closing in January due to a gas issue, has gone for good.

On Monday, April 4, the pizzeria held a public auction to clear out its equipment before closing its doors once again.

One of the owners, who introduced himself as Tony but didn’t want his last name mentioned, said he would have stayed had he been offered a “fair lease,” but also indicated there were other factors like a vent that wasn’t up to building code, which he said the landlord had concerns about. However, on the latter issue, Tony said he couldn’t have it fixed. “If it was something simple, we would have addressed it,” he said.

Tony isn’t currently planning to reopen Mariella’s at another location.

“If we could find a good spot that’s affordable in the area, we might,” Tony said. “We had a very good following. The community wants us to be here.”
As T&V reported last week, Con Ed said the gas was shut off in the building on January 24 because of an odor, but the utility was able to turn it back on by February 22. While the gas was eventually switched back on, the restaurant never reopened.

Tony explained that while the owners hadn’t planned to close due to the gas issue, they faced an uphill battle after five weeks of closure, because his employees moved on and he lost a significant amount of inventory.

He went on to say he’s noticed that businesses “everywhere,” but in particular First Avenue have been getting displaced. “People are going out,” said Tony. “It’s very difficult for the little guys.

“It’s a sad thing,” he added. “It’s a very emotional day. We never thought we’d go out of business. But things happen.”

He declined to name the landlord, but data from the website of the Department of Housing Preservation and the Development linked the address, 180 Third Avenue, which is at the corner of East 16th Street, to an address for residential apartments at the same property, 145 East 16th Street. That property is listed as being owned by Allan and Jane Goldman of Solil Management. A call to that company was forwarded to a person who manages the commercial spaces, who didn’t respond to a request for comment.

Meanwhile, outside the pizza shop on Monday morning, one man walking by, upon noticing the “Public auction sign,’ declared, “It’s a tragedy.” He then snapped a photo before moving on. A couple of other passersby also stopped briefly in the rain in disbelief.

Elsewhere on the block, a small Mexican restaurant across the street called La Paloma sported a “for rent” sign. Up the block at the corner of East 16th Street, the space that was last home to Met Food supermarket, which closed a year ago, was still vacant, while a space next store has recently become an urgent care center run by North Shore LIJ.

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “Mariella Pizza closes doors after 37 years

  1. So sad that another perfectly fine small business leaves the Gramercy area. Soon we will be left with $5 pizza and craft donuts. Mariella was generous with well priced salads, pizza and meals. Delivery was fast. So sad.

  2. Pres. Bill Clinton at Community Center and T&V knew nothing about it?????

    Sent from my Verizon Wireless 4G LTE DROID

    Town & Village Blog wrote:

    > a:hover { color: red; } a { text-decoration: none; color: #0088cc; } a.primaryactionlink:link, a.primaryactionlink:visited { background-color: #2585B2; color: #fff; } a.primaryactionlink:hover, a.primaryactionlink:active { background-color: #11729E !important; color: #fff !important; } /* @media only screen and (max-device-width: 480px) { .post { min-width: 700px !important; } } */ WordPress.com Town & Village Blog posted: ” By Sabina Mollot Mariella Pizza, which had slung slices for 37 years on Third Avenue before closing in January due to a gas issue, has gone for good. On Monday, April 4, the pizzeria held a public auction to clear out its equipment before closing its doo”

  3. As my dear friend once said:
    “People always complain about how New Yorkers say the pizza sucks everywhere else. But I say to them: ‘F— YOU! THE PIZZA SUCKS EVERYWHERE ELSE!’ ”
    He and I grew up a few blocks from Mariella’s and we went there frequently all through elementary school and high school. On trips back to New York the first question we’d always ask each other was “Did you go to Mariella’s?”
    That place will always be the place that I think of when I think of New York pizza. Back in the era of the Tama Fair on 3rd Avenue (the late 1900’s), they would always make a giant pizza about 10′ across. It was a significant feature of my childhood, a landmark and a living memory of greasy savor I could revisit whenever I was in town. Proust’s cookies have nothing on a New York slice from the place you went for pizza with your best childhood friend.
    If New York succumbs one day to rising sea levels and is lost like Atlantis, my first tear would be for my mother’s rent controlled apartment further up 3rd avenue and the second tear would be for Mariella’s.

  4. I think you meant businesses on Third Avenue (not First Avenue). Between 16th & 17th — because within a year, longtime businesses closed: Met Food closed. La Paloma’s closed. Mumbles closed. Now Mariella’s. The North Shore LIJ urgent care replaces a different Urgent Care that closed after a year or two. Mariella’s was such a great part to the neighborhood. Very kind proprietor and workers. Very happy neighborhood take-out and meeting place. GREAT NEW YORK PIZZA

  5. We are becoming “Amalgam Town, USA” Why do we pay such high rents to live in a suburb that used to be a great, fascinating and I replicated city? Lower my rent and pass the Starbucks. Yawn. These small towns are so homogenized and boring

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s