Bills aim to exempt some businesses from paying Commercial Rent tax

Garodnick with other local elected officials and small business owners at City Hall on Monday. (Photo by Maria Rocha-Buschel)

Garodnick with other local elected officials and small business owners at City Hall on Monday to discuss a package of bills. (Photo by Maria Rocha-Buschel)

By Maria Rocha-Buschel

Local elected officials gathered at City Hall on Monday to announce legislation that would exempt almost 4,000 local businesses in Manhattan from paying Commercial Rent Tax (CRT), which currently subjects owners below 96th Street to an additional tax if their yearly rent is $250,000 or higher. Councilmembers Dan Garodnick, Helen Rosenthal, Corey Johnson and Margaret Chin, along with Manhattan Borough President Gale Brewer, introduced the three bills aimed at providing relief for small business owners.

One of the bills, introduced by Garodnick and Rosenthal, would increase the rent threshold so commercial tenants paying under $500,000 would not have to pay the tax. Johnson and Brewer also introduced legislation aimed at helping affordable supermarkets and would exempt those businesses from the CRT, regardless of the amount of rent they pay.

The CRT was introduced in 1963 to help increase revenue in the city but was phased out in the Bronx, Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island and even the northern part of Manhattan in the 1990s, and the current rent threshold has not been updated since 2001. Brewer noted that the tax previously made sense because it was primarily applied to larger businesses but since rents have continued to increase, small and medium-sized businesses are affected now as well.

Garodnick noted that small businesses such as hardware stores, restaurants and boutiques which are sometimes already struggling to pay rent are put in further jeopardy by the additional cost of the tax.

“This is one of the prime culprits that is worsening the affordability problem and this legislation will give them some relief,” he said.

Johnson added that in addition to being a detriment to the owners, the loss of small businesses because of an inability to keep pace with costs has a negative effect on the neighborhood’s character.

“If locksmiths, bodegas and local pharmacies close and keep getting replaced by banks, that affects the quality of life and affordability of the neighborhood, and it affects the rapid gentrification of the neighborhood,” he said.

On the supermarket protection bill, Brewer said, “I’ve been to too many rallies recently to keep supermarkets open. Too many affordable supermarkets are being threatened with closure. One factor is the rising rents, and my legislation will give affordable supermarkets an exemption. We want to make sure that the number of affordable supermarkets doesn’t get any smaller.”

Other bills in the package of legislation would require the Department of Finance to issue an annual report on the commercial rent tax and would extend the CRT exemption to include the cost of space used for advertising theatrical works.


6 thoughts on “Bills aim to exempt some businesses from paying Commercial Rent tax

  1. Like Edmund said on Facebook, this is just another smokescreen for Dan’s continued opposition to SBJSA. What good will this tax be if there are no more small businesses, and we are surrounded by Starbucks, CVS, Chase, and City MD?

  2. He’s for small businesses, he’s against small businesses, he’s for small businesses, he’s against small businesses…..Ultimately, it all depends on who he’s lying to at the minute he is asked the question. Now he’s trying to woo voters so he’s for it in public, against them in private with his REBNY overlords…After all, he is Dan Dan the flim flam man….

  3. Another day, another Garodnick press conference.

    Hey Danny Boy, when are you actually going to deliver something for our community?

    We’ve been waiting eleven years.

  4. Pingback: Republican small business owner challenging Maloney | Town & Village

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.