Opinion: Felder overplays his hand

By former Assmeblyman Steven Sanders

Brooklyn State Senator Simcha Felder is a Democrat. But for reasons best known to him, he has been caucusing with the Republicans in Albany to help enable that Party to maintain control of the State Senate in spite of having fewer members than the Democrats.

But that’s not where the story ends. Last month, the seven Democratic members who have made up the so called “Independent Democratic Caucus” for the past number of years, reluctantly returned to the reservation. That leaves the Senate composition at 32 Democrats and 31 Republicans. Governor Cuomo for years tacitly accepted that odd political marriage because he felt it worked to his advantage. He no longer thinks so. He has been pressured from the left, and from his primary opponent Cynthia Nixon, to stand up for Democrats. So he suddenly got involved and brokered a deal amongst the Senate Democrats.

But with Felder’s continued affiliation with the Republicans, they will maintain Senate control for the rest of this year. In exchange for Mr. Felder’s support, the Republicans have given him legislative perks and pivotal voting deference. But as the current session winds down and the November elections loom large and soon, Mr. Felder’s political strategy may need rethinking.

There are now five Republican incumbent senators who have announced their retirement. And at least four of those seats are winnable for the Democrats this year. They only need to win one to control the Senate next year regardless of what Mr. Felder does, assuming he can win reelection. Should that occur Mr. Felder will find his influence reduced to zero since the Democrats won’t need him and the Republicans can no longer use him to boost their majority control of the House.

So Senator Felder, who today sits in the driver’s seat, may soon find himself in the caboose. However, for the time being, as Republicans continue to control the Senate, they maintain decision making over the flow of legislation and as such will continue to keep bottled up pro-tenant and pro-consumer bills some of which are of great importance to Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper residents. Felder’s peculiar alignment with the Republican Party has real consequences for public policy.

Politics is a lot like poker. You get dealt a hand and then you try to improve upon it and then decide whether to continue to play or not. It’s time for Senator Felder to fold.

One thought on “Opinion: Felder overplays his hand

  1. For the many years that the IDC created Democratic party dysfunction, Felder said publicly that he has voted with the GOP for majority leader because it was the best way for him to get things for his district. It was a lame excuse then and a lame excuse now.

    Look at Felder’s rating by the NY Conservative Party. It’s 72 out of 100. That’s the same kind of rating Cathy Young and other ultra-conservatives get. By comparison, Liz Krueger’s rating is around 40.

    Felder is a DINO. And actually the same can be said for some members of the IDC.

    If Bloomberg could run as a Republican and Felder as a Democrat, the labels don’t matter so much as the political campaigns run against them and what the press exposes about them.

    Felder has been given a pass by the party regulars. I’ve heard all kinds of excuses made for him.

    This guy is a Benedict Arnold for the Democrats. Unless he’s seriously threatened politically and gets the kind of press he deserves, I expect the Senate will remain in the hands of the Republicans. The State Democratic Party has been far too tolerant and accommodating with this guy.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.