Arthur Z. Schwartz discusses the litigation at an April press conference. (Photo by Sabina Mollot)
By Sabina Mollot
In April, Arthur Z. Schwartz, an attorney for Advocates for Justice, filed a lawsuit in an attempt to stop the L train shutdown planned for 2019. The litigation, filed on behalf of a coalition of West Side residents living on or near 14th Street and disability advocacy groups, was over the lack of access for disabled passengers in the plan to upgrade various stations along the L train route.
The lawsuit is also over area residents’ concerns about traffic congestion, due to a planned “busway” on 14th Street and expanded sidewalks causing traffic to be congested on surrounding streets. The Metropolitan Transportation Authority, the Department of Transportation and the Federal Transportation Authority were named as defendants.
However, Schwartz, who’s also a Greenwich Village Democratic district leader, announced late last month that the suit was partially settled with the MTA proposing to make the Sixth Avenue station accessible to the disabled. Previously only two stations included in the renovation plan (Bedford Avenue and First Avenue) were slated to become compliant with the Americans with Disabilities Act.
In exchange, the part of the lawsuit alleging disregard for disabled New Yorkers has been dropped. This was first reported by The Villager.
Stuyvesant Town Security Chief Bill McClellan and General Manager Sean Sullivan address residents at a town hall meeting on Tuesday. Photo by Maria Rocha-Buschel
By Maria Rocha-Buschel
General Manager Sean Sullivan hosted a town hall meeting for Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper Village residents last Tuesday, the first such meeting in a number of years. Sullivan noted at the beginning of the meeting that its purpose was an informal gathering to talk with seniors about residential programming and the community center, but it quickly became clear that residents had other things on their minds. Security issues, Sandy-related problems and the rising student population were some of the main concerns of tenants at the meeting.
In light of the keycard failures during Sandy, one resident asked Sullivan at the beginning of the meeting if it would be possible to put regular cylinders with physical keys back on apartment doors.
“You may not like some of my responses but I’m going to try to be straight with you tonight,” Sullivan said. “The short answer is no. It’s a system that we put in place and it works. (Sandy) was an extraordinary moment in time and we took extraordinary measures.” Residents responded to this, frustrated, saying the system obviously does not work if it failed for so long after the storm, but Sullivan noted that Sandy was not a typical scenario. “Battery backup for the keycard system will work in a typical outage,” he said.
In addition to the keycard failures, other residents noted that the emergency lights in the stairwells failed as well. Sullivan said that there is a battery backup for these as well but they did not last as long as the outage because they were only meant to be used for hours at a time, not days. When tenants specified that there were cases in which the lighting did not even last for hours after the blackout, Sullivan said that he wasn’t aware of this issue and would look into it.
Many Peter Cooper Village residents were on hand at the meeting to express frustrations about the lack of laundry services, as well as the partial elevator service that still exists in some of the buildings.
“My husband is in a wheelchair. We waited two and a half hours because the one elevator was out (a couple weeks ago),” one resident said. “You can keep your memos about the landscaping. Restoring elevator service should be your number one priority. All we’ve got is reassurances and no definitive information.”
After heckling from other meeting attendees about the lack of a concrete date, Sullivan said the hope is that all elevator service will be restored by the end of this month, and attempted to explain why the process has been so lengthy.
“They’re not broken, they’re gone,” he said. “The workers are rebuilding the elevators in the shaft from scratch. We were fortunate to get in the queue. There were a lot of manufacturers that stopped taking orders because the need was just so high (after Sandy). There is no profit for us to move any slower on this.”
As for laundry, service for residents without it in Peter Cooper Village will still have a few months to wait.
“We’ve said that laundry service would be fully restored by September of this year. I’m not changing their timeline but we are trying to do better than that,” he said. “We’re focused on restoring these services. We don’t want you to be frustrated, but the damage was significant and severe. I understand the level of frustration and I don’t want to diminish it for a moment. We’re working on it. It’s not a great solution but we’re doing our best.”
Although noise and late-night rowdiness from the community’s younger population has been a recent complaint of many residents in this newspaper’s letters to the editor, residents at the meeting were more bothered by the transient nature of students in Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper Village. The constant moving in and out of short-term tenants was a point of concern for those at the meeting. Some residents noted that it even becomes a frustrating security issue because building doors have been propped open while people are moving. “It happens every month, sometimes in the middle of the month as well,” one resident said at the meeting. “When I bring it up to them, security says, ‘oh it’s fine.’ But it’s not fine. It’s a safety issue.”
ST/PCV Security Chief Bill McClellan said that alarms are set to go off if a door has been propped open for three minutes. They’ve also sent people to close doors and tell movers that they can’t prop the doors open, but residents at the meeting were frustrated that this was not helping, one noting that she had told movers herself not to prop the door open and the mover cursed at her.
A resident of 541 East 20th Street said that she was concerned about safety issues as well after maintenance had entered her apartment to install an intercom without notice or permission, and was especially disturbed after hearing about the reports of burglaries in the community.
Sullivan said that maintenance is supposed to reach out to tenants beforehand and for tenants that don’t respond, maintenance may come back multiple times to deal with these exceptions. After not specifically addressing the resident’s situation, other attendees at the meeting became frustrated, yelling while Sullivan attempted to move on to another question.
In response to concerns about the thefts possibly being related to recent maintenance work, Sullivan added that public safety is supposed to escort outside contractors to the apartments to supervise but otherwise had no information about why this incident occurred at the building on East 20th Street.
In some of the less contentious moments of the evening, Sullivan did announce that the gym is expected to reopen in just a few weeks.
He also noted, to the appreciation of the tenants at the meeting, that the doors in the community center would be replaced by automatic sliding doors, similar to those in supermarkets, because there have been issues with seniors walking into the doors or having difficult getting them open.
Dear Mr. Hagedorn:
I have lived and raised my children in Stuyvesant Town for the past 32 years. And I have been a subscriber to Town & Village for all those years, enjoying the community news and reports. These past years I have noticed a certain tilt to extreme left political views in your articles and opinions such as the column of Mr. Wally Dobelis. I choose to skip over his writings.
However, I draw the line with the extreme left cartoon insulting (“GOP and GOP’ier,” depicting two men named Romney and Ryan, the Republican Party nominees no less, beating on an elderly woman lying down on the street grounds). This cartoon by J.Meadows is very offensive to those of us that are Americans and GOP’ers.
Furthermore, I am a senior citizen, recently retired and very much involved in the running of our beloved country. The extreme left has taken over the Democratic Party and no longer hides its goal: to do away with the Republican Party and eventually turn our beloved country into a dictatorship. Those in the extreme left Democratic Party no longer hide their distaste and their hatred toward their fellow Americans in the Republican Party.
Contrary to the Democratic Party, we (the GOP’ers) do not wish harm to our fellow Americans. We believe in our Constitution, our Two-Party system and our freedom. I am therefore asking you to balance out the cartoons you so liberally shove down our souls by printing a cartoon just as offensive to “Democrat & Democrat”iers showing President Barack Hussein Obama bowing down to the King of Saudi Arabia, or telling the American people that “They did not build their business” or how he granted presidential immunity to Eric Holder to save him from being impeached for lying to Congress for the “Fast and Furious” cover-up scandal. Or how he robbed the Medicare Program by 725 billion dollars to help pass Obamacare.
While President Obama is running our nation’s debts by the trillions of dollars each year since he took office and in the pretext of wanting to redistribute the wealth in this country, he has taken our tax money and give it to his rich pals to finance their failed businesses such as the Solyndra fiasco. Posing as the president that cares mostly for the “poor,” he rubs elbows with the super rich of Hollywood and the likes of multi-billionaire, America-hater George Soros. Oh, and let’s not forget the entire leftist media starting with WCBS, WNBC, WABC, PBS, CNN, HBO etc… NY Times, Daily News, Washington Post, etc… that carries this president’s water in the fear of appearing racist.
I expect my neighborhood newspaper to give me the news concerning my neighborhood and not to insult me and other Republicans citizens by publishing the hateful cartoons of J. Meadows. Have the courage to be fair and balanced.
Jeannette Shuck, ST
Editor’s note: This newspaper appreciates the points made. We hope that the cartoons we run show this publication’s willingness to spoof all politicians and parties equally. Continue reading →